What if some of the behaviors we associate with spiritual maturity have more to do with cultural familiarity than Christlikeness?
One of the more sobering realizations I’ve had in recent months is that a person can spend years serving in the Church, developing relationships, exercising spiritual gifts, and participating in Christian community while still feeling fundamentally misunderstood. I know because I’ve experienced it.
I’m 40 years old, have served in various ministry capacities throughout much of my adult life, and only recently learned that I’m autistic (Level 1). That discovery has helped me better understand decades of experiences, particularly the challenges I’ve encountered navigating professional relationships, ministry environments, and the unspoken expectations that accompany both. But it has also prompted a question I believe the Church needs to wrestle with:
Have we sometimes confused becoming more like Christ with becoming more like everyone else?
I don’t ask that question as someone who has abandoned the Church. I continue to serve in ministry, believe deeply in the importance of Christian community, and remain convinced that the local church is an essential expression of God’s redemptive work in the world. But loving the Church should never require us to ignore the ways our communities sometimes fall short of their calling.
When Hospitality Doesn’t Become Belonging
I’ve encountered some extraordinarily compassionate believers throughout my Christian journey. Some of the safest relationships I’ve experienced have been with longtime intercessors whose walks with the Lord have cultivated remarkable patience, discernment, humility, and the ability to remain present when relationships become complicated.
These individuals haven’t necessarily possessed specialized knowledge of autism or neurodivergence. What they’ve demonstrated is something equally important: a willingness to listen before drawing conclusions, to extend grace without demanding explanations, and to recognize that another person’s experience may differ significantly from their own. I’ve also seen churches create meaningful opportunities for people to serve, develop their gifts, grow in biblical understanding, and participate in genuine fellowship. Those experiences deserve recognition.
But I’ve also noticed a troubling distinction between being welcomed into Christian community and actually experiencing belonging within it.
Hospitality can be expressed through a friendly greeting, an invitation to a small group, or an opportunity to volunteer. Belonging requires something more substantial. It involves being known, understood, valued, and loved beyond the expectations of a particular social environment. For neurodivergent Christians, that distinction can be enormous.
A church may genuinely welcome someone while unintentionally creating a culture in which that person must continually suppress or disguise aspects of their neurological differences to remain socially accepted. And when acceptance depends on becoming someone you’re not, we should ask whether we’ve confused inclusion with conformity.
When Neurological Differences Become Spiritual Problems
One of the more concerning patterns I’ve observed is how easily differences in communication, emotional processing, and social interaction can become spiritualized. Direct communication may be interpreted as disrespect. A desire for clarity can be mistaken for inflexibility. Asking difficult questions may be perceived as challenging authority. Difficulty navigating social expectations can be labeled immaturity, while unfamiliar expressions of emotion may be mistaken for indifference or instability.
These interpretations can become particularly consequential in ministry environments, where spiritual language carries considerable weight. A person may be described as prideful, stubborn, unsubmissive, divisive, or lacking in spiritual maturity when the underlying issue is actually a difference in how that person processes information, communicates, or understands relationships.
To be clear, autism does not exempt anyone from accountability, correction, repentance, or spiritual formation. Neurodivergent Christians, like every other believer, are called to grow in the character of Christ. But…
There is a profound difference between confronting genuine sin and correcting someone for failing to meet an expectation Scripture never established.
Tweet
Consider how frequently Christian community is organized around social conventions: spontaneous conversation, crowded fellowship spaces, highly interactive small groups, indirect communication, and expectations about how enthusiasm, reverence, or emotional engagement should appear. None of these things is inherently wrong, but neither should they become universal measurements of spiritual health.
Someone who finds a crowded church lobby overwhelming may still deeply desire Christian fellowship. Someone who struggles to interpret indirect feedback may be extraordinarily teachable when expectations are communicated clearly. Someone whose emotional expressions differ from what others anticipate may possess profound compassion and spiritual sensitivity. The problem emerges when we interpret unfamiliar behavior through familiar assumptions and then attach spiritual significance to those assumptions.

One Body, Many Members
Paul’s description of the Church in 1 Corinthians 12 offers an important corrective. The Body of Christ is not composed of interchangeable members who demonstrate their faithfulness by functioning identically. It is composed of different members, each possessing distinct gifts, responsibilities, and contributions.
Paul goes further by challenging the assumption that some members are less necessary because they appear weaker or less prominent. In 1 Corinthians 12:22, he writes that the members of the body that seem weaker are indispensable. His argument is not simply that difference should be tolerated. It is that the Body of Christ depends upon its members recognizing their mutual need for one another.
What might happen if we applied that principle more intentionally to neurodivergent believers? What if the person who notices inconsistencies others overlook is not automatically considered difficult? What if the individual who asks unusually detailed questions is recognized as someone pursuing understanding rather than challenging authority? What if the believer who struggles with conventional social interaction is still recognized as capable of extraordinary loyalty, wisdom, discernment, and spiritual depth?
Certainly, not every autistic person possesses the same strengths or experiences the same challenges. Neurodivergence is not a uniform collection of gifts any more than it is a uniform collection of limitations. But the theological principle remains…
Difference does not diminish someone’s place within the Body of Christ.
Tweet
And the Church should be particularly careful about dismissing contributions simply because they arrive through unfamiliar personalities or communication styles.
The Ministry of Presence
My wife and I have experienced both remarkable compassion and painful absence within Christian community, particularly following the loss of our daughter, Jubilee, in 2022. I won’t attempt to unpack those experiences here, except to say that suffering has a way of revealing the difference between community as an aspiration and community as a lived reality.
It’s one thing to affirm that we bear one another’s burdens. It’s another to remain present when grief becomes prolonged, relationships become complicated, or someone’s needs don’t fit the expectations we’ve grown accustomed to. Romans 12:15 calls believers to rejoice with those who rejoice and mourn with those who mourn. That instruction does not prescribe a particular personality, communication style, or emotional response. It calls us into the experiences of others.
For me, some of the most meaningful expressions of Christian love have come from people who didn’t attempt to explain away difficult emotions or demand that I process them differently. They listened, prayed, and remained present. Perhaps most importantly, they made room for experiences they didn’t fully understand. That kind of presence is not exclusive to neurodivergent ministry. It’s fundamental to Christian discipleship.
A Church That Practices What It Proclaims
So what would a healthier, more neurodivergent-aware Church actually look like? I don’t believe the answer necessarily begins with elaborate programs, specialized ministries, or an expectation that every pastor becomes an expert in autism. Those resources may have tremendous value, but genuine cultural change begins with something more foundational: humility.
Church leaders can learn to ask questions before assigning motives. Ministry teams can communicate expectations clearly rather than relying on unwritten social rules. Small groups can recognize that meaningful fellowship doesn’t always require identical forms of participation. Congregations can create room for people who connect through thoughtful conversation, shared service, structured learning, or quieter forms of community.
When misunderstandings occur, believers can approach one another with curiosity rather than immediately assuming the worst. This doesn’t eliminate the need for biblical accountability. It makes accountability more responsible by ensuring we’re addressing actual concerns rather than merely reacting to unfamiliar behavior.
I would also argue that neurodivergent awareness should not be separated from spiritual maturity. A church can possess considerable theological knowledge while struggling to demonstrate relational patience. Conversely, an individual can understand autism terminology without exhibiting the humility, compassion, or selflessness that characterize Christlike love. We need both.
The goal isn’t to replace biblical discipleship with psychological categories. It’s to recognize that understanding the people we’re discipling can help us apply biblical principles with greater wisdom and care.
Beyond Sunday
Ultimately, this conversation extends well beyond the walls of a sanctuary. The same assumptions that cause friction within Christian community often follow us into workplaces, families, friendships, and leadership relationships.
How do we respond when someone’s communication style makes us uncomfortable? When their questions challenge our assumptions? When their emotional response differs from what we expected? Do we approach them with patience and curiosity, or do we assign motives before seeking understanding?
These aren’t merely questions about neurodivergence. They’re questions about the kind of people we’re becoming as followers of Jesus. If our faith is meant to shape how we love our neighbors, then it must also shape how we respond to neighbors whose minds work differently from our own.
I still love the Church. I still believe in its calling. And I remain hopeful that Christian communities can grow in their ability to recognize, disciple, and empower neurodivergent believers. But I believe that growth will require us to examine some uncomfortable assumptions about what spiritual maturity is supposed to look like.
I don’t think neurodivergent Christians are asking the Church to lower its biblical expectations. We’re asking it to consider whether some of its cultural expectations have been mistaken for biblical ones.
And perhaps that’s a question worth carrying with us long after Sunday morning has ended.

